Unfortunately I was disappointed in this book. I had many,
many high hopes for it after reading and watching so many rave reviews. The writing was phenomenal, and after the
first 100 pages or so, I fell into the English countryside and was devouring
the book in large chunks. That is where
my positive experience ends. I was
expecting a creepy book with a Gothic setting, plot twists and turns that would
keep me awake at night and a thrilling conclusion. Instead I received a plot that moved slowly,
with characters that I didn't like and an unsatisfying ending. After thinking over this novel for a few days, I
still cannot determine the motives of the doctor (whose name I even can’t
remember) which I believe was a larger portion of the book than what has
otherwise been suggested. Overall I
wouldn't recommend this book to others but I am going to keep reading other
Sarah Waters books.
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 13, 2015
The Little Stranger | Mini Review
I finished reading The Little Stranger by Sarah Waters a few days ago. It is an incredibly hyped up book right now and I couldn't stop hearing about it on BookTube. For everyone who hasn't heard of this book yet, you can check out the Goodreads page for a plot summary. I am always afraid that I will reveal spoiler-y information in a plot summary I write myself.
Wednesday, October 8, 2014
Belzhar by Meg Wolitzer | Review
![]() |
| Source: Goole Books |
I picked up Belzhar after hearing about it on Book Riot’s Youtube channel and a million other places on the internet book world - I couldn’t get away from it as an anticipated new release for the fall. I promptly put it on my library request list and forgot about it. I already own two other books by Wolitzer, The Wife and The Position, that I haven't read yet. But with endless recommendations for her writing style and story crafting, and the kick in the pants YA has on my reading habits, I jumped in headfirst and finished Belzhar within 72 hours of picking it up.
Belzhar is about Jam, a 15 year old girl who is sent to The Wooden Barn boarding school for “highly intelligent and emotionally fragile” teenagers after the trauma of losing her British exchange student boyfriend, Reeve. At the Wooden Barn, Jam is placed in the Special Topics in English class with four other students hand picked (for mysterious reasons) by Mrs. Quennell. Mrs. Q helps these five teens heal over the course of one semester by teaching The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath and requiring students to journal about themselves. What happens when the students journal allow them to become a close knit group of friends (almost like a secret society) and overcome the hardships that brought them to The Wooden Barn.
I liked this book for several reasons. Personally, my entire undergraduate degree was focused on the psychology of school-aged students so this hit home to me on an academic level. I think mental health is a very important topic that should be taught to young adults in schools, at home, in the media, etc., but doesn’t receive much attention. Meg Wolitzer creates characters with backgrounds that are relatable enough for people who have not experienced trauma to remain sympathetic and empathetic to the experiences the characters have had. She brings attention to their mental health issues (depression, binge eating, withdrawal) and emotions (fear, anger, resentment, remorse) without making the issue or emotion the sole defining trait of the character.
Secondly, the emphasis that Wolitzer put on introspection and journaling was constructive and realistic and generally awesome even though not every character had a happy ending. At the end of the 260ish page book, despite making growth in their personal journeys to overcome their experiences, every character was not fully healed. But they were able to function better in their daily lives and form relationships with new people because of their journals. I think this is a great message for the teens that are going to read this book.
The main drawback I felt while reading this book was the lack of depth with the characters. Even though every character had a reason to be at the The Wooden Barn, none were explained or explored in a below the surface context. As a young adult reader, that much depth might not be necessary to pull you into the book, but I think that would have added a lot more for adult readers. There was also a lot of telling instead of experiencing about the healing each character experienced, specifically at the conclusion of the novel when the characters wrote in their journals for the last time.
Overall I enjoyed Belzhar book for the value it will provide to young adult readers and the contribution to mental health literature but I wouldn't recommend this to everyone. I think young adults, teachers, and parents would get the most out of this book. It brings emotional growth and development of adolescents into the forefront of your mind and makes you think about the validity of emotional experiences adolescents have instead of writing them off as hormonal or growing pains.
Wednesday, August 27, 2014
Landline Review
Landline by Rainbow Rowell was published a few weeks ago and was automatically added to my TBR; I requested it from my library so far in advance I was the second person to be added to the wait list. I like to call Rainbow Rowell's books my "one hit wonders" because I always finish them in one sitting, so I added this book to my Bout of Books 11.0 TBR and successfully finished it in one sitting at three o'clock in the morning. Now I can check off the box on my Bookish Bucket List of reading an author's entire published work. Rainbow Rowell's writing and storytelling capabilities are like sinking into a bubble bath: comfortable. I knew I was going to enjoy this book even before I knew what it was about.
Landline tells the story of Georgie McCool and the events that unfold when she stays in California one week over Christmas to pursue her lifelong dream of pitching her own sitcom to network executives instead of travelling to Nebraska with her family . When we meet Georgie, she has devoted her entire existence to being a sitcom writer and mother which resulted in a strained marriage to Neal, her stay at home husband. During the week that she is separated from her family. Georgie tries to call Neal from the old landline phone in her childhood bedroom and ends up talking to the Neal from 1998, before they were engaged. Georgie uses these phone calls to repair her relationship with her husband to find out what went wrong in their marriage.
I enjoyed this book and I am glad I read it but I feel like it came up short (I felt the same way about Rowell's other adult contemporary Attachments. She doesn't seem to have this problem with her YA books). I do not want to delve into spoilers, but throughout the novel, it seemed like Georgie was being forced to choose her marriage or her career, with a greater emphasis on the importance to her marriage. I am not saying that her marriage is not important- as a married lady myself, I agree that Georgie needed to refocus on her marriage to repair the years of damage that we witness in this novel. However, I think Georgie should have been able to fix her marriage and still have her career but the novel ended before that could happen.
Did you read Landline and feel the same way? Let me know in the comments!
Landline tells the story of Georgie McCool and the events that unfold when she stays in California one week over Christmas to pursue her lifelong dream of pitching her own sitcom to network executives instead of travelling to Nebraska with her family . When we meet Georgie, she has devoted her entire existence to being a sitcom writer and mother which resulted in a strained marriage to Neal, her stay at home husband. During the week that she is separated from her family. Georgie tries to call Neal from the old landline phone in her childhood bedroom and ends up talking to the Neal from 1998, before they were engaged. Georgie uses these phone calls to repair her relationship with her husband to find out what went wrong in their marriage.
I enjoyed this book and I am glad I read it but I feel like it came up short (I felt the same way about Rowell's other adult contemporary Attachments. She doesn't seem to have this problem with her YA books). I do not want to delve into spoilers, but throughout the novel, it seemed like Georgie was being forced to choose her marriage or her career, with a greater emphasis on the importance to her marriage. I am not saying that her marriage is not important- as a married lady myself, I agree that Georgie needed to refocus on her marriage to repair the years of damage that we witness in this novel. However, I think Georgie should have been able to fix her marriage and still have her career but the novel ended before that could happen.
Did you read Landline and feel the same way? Let me know in the comments!
Friday, August 22, 2014
Anna and the French Kiss Series Review
Prior to reading the trilogy of Stephanie Perkins' three books Anna and the French Kiss, Lola and the Boy Next Door, and Isla and the Happily Ever After I was an anti-romance YA reader. I preferred dystopian, fantasy, or horror books - as far from romance as you could get until the buzz surrounding Anna and the French Kiss was unavoidable.
I picked up Anna in February 2013 because it was a kindle daily deal, and it was Valentine's Day, and I stayed up until the wee hours of the morning to finish the book. The next day at work, I was bleary eyed and tired but it was well worth it for the witty, funny, and gushy romance I have read the night before. I repeated the same experience for Lola and the Boy Next Door and Isla and the Happily Ever After, both times pre-ordering the books on my kindle so I could read them as soon as possible. Now that all three books in the series have been released, and I read them individually, I want to marathon them back to back to experience Anna, Lola and Isla fall in love all over again.
I have linked each book's Goodread pages above so you can read more plot summary of the individual books. If you are in the mood for light, funny, sometimes heart wrenching but ultimately satisfying books, I highly recommend all three of Stephanie's novels, even if you are a non-romance reader like I was. These books capture something genuine about first time love and heartbreak that make stand out amongst their peers and are definitely worth a read.
Wednesday, August 20, 2014
The Night Circus Review
Just short of a year ago, I posted this review of The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern confessing my inability to finish the audiobook and not for lack of trying. I loved the atmosphere that narrator Jim Dale brought to the already rick text of the book but I couldn't follow the plot of the book because it crosses decades and continents from one page to the next. I didn't forget about it, though, and I picked up the paperback a couple of months ago at Books a Million to try again.
The Night Circus weaves a tale of competition, love, and a young man's true calling throughout it's 500 pages. It is fantastical, yet grounded in reality, as you watch the creation of a larger than life circus become a magical exposition center for Celia and Marco to compete against one another in an unexplained, vague contest that they were bound to at six years old At the same time, you experience the circus through Bailey's eyes as an adolescent and how he and the circus change over time.
This is a phenomenal book. Erin Morgenstern takes the time to craft a story that appeals to all five senses - I have been thinking about the caramel popcorn descriptions in this book since last year. The Night Circus primarily takes place in Victorian England, a time period just far enough in the past to be unfamiliar. There is enough magic, romance, and suspense to push the plot forward while relishing in each vignette written about the characters. If you are thinking about picking this book up, do it! I highly recommend it and I can't wait for Morgenstern's next release.
The Night Circus weaves a tale of competition, love, and a young man's true calling throughout it's 500 pages. It is fantastical, yet grounded in reality, as you watch the creation of a larger than life circus become a magical exposition center for Celia and Marco to compete against one another in an unexplained, vague contest that they were bound to at six years old At the same time, you experience the circus through Bailey's eyes as an adolescent and how he and the circus change over time.
![]() |
| Photo Credit to Greeneiris at Fan Pop |
This is a phenomenal book. Erin Morgenstern takes the time to craft a story that appeals to all five senses - I have been thinking about the caramel popcorn descriptions in this book since last year. The Night Circus primarily takes place in Victorian England, a time period just far enough in the past to be unfamiliar. There is enough magic, romance, and suspense to push the plot forward while relishing in each vignette written about the characters. If you are thinking about picking this book up, do it! I highly recommend it and I can't wait for Morgenstern's next release.
Thursday, April 10, 2014
The Hangman's Daughter | Review
The Hangman's Daughter was published in 2008 and is the first in a quartet written by Oliver Potzch. This book chronicles a witch hunt that takes placed in Germany during the 1660s after a boy mysteriously dies at the town's dock. This sets off a series of children's deaths that are complicated by local economic and political conflicts, as well as the ethical and moral implications of a witch hunt. The local hangman, his daughter, and the town physician set out to unravel the mystery of the deaths to ensure the right culprit is punished.
I purchased this book on my Kindle on accident - it was on the Daily Deal and I thought I was purchasing The Madman's Daughter, a YA spin-off from The Island of Doctor Moreau. Surprisingly,despite what I thought I was originally reading the plot of The Hangman's Daughter was really intriguing. I enjoyed getting the local politics and folklore of Schongau and unravelling the mystery of the murders. The plot frequently changed perspectives- first a third person perspective of the town, and then a first person perspective from the mysterious murder.
The first 80% of the book was great, the plot was fast paced and it was detailed enough to understand the conflicting relationships between all of the townspeople for really fleshed out characters and culture. However, once the mystery started unravelling the book fell flat for me and I wasn't interested in finding out who the murdered was. To be quite honest, this might not be the book's fault- I have the same problem with other mystery and horror novels that I read, where the build up is more exciting than the resolution. Some of the mystery may have been lost in the translation as well (originally written in German).
Overall, the end I ended up only giving the book 2/5 stars on Goodreads but despite that low rating I would still recommend it to anyone looking for a well developed, character driven plot. I do not plan on reading the other three books in The Hangman's Daughter quartet.
![]() |
| Source Image: Goodreads |
I purchased this book on my Kindle on accident - it was on the Daily Deal and I thought I was purchasing The Madman's Daughter, a YA spin-off from The Island of Doctor Moreau. Surprisingly,despite what I thought I was originally reading the plot of The Hangman's Daughter was really intriguing. I enjoyed getting the local politics and folklore of Schongau and unravelling the mystery of the murders. The plot frequently changed perspectives- first a third person perspective of the town, and then a first person perspective from the mysterious murder.
The first 80% of the book was great, the plot was fast paced and it was detailed enough to understand the conflicting relationships between all of the townspeople for really fleshed out characters and culture. However, once the mystery started unravelling the book fell flat for me and I wasn't interested in finding out who the murdered was. To be quite honest, this might not be the book's fault- I have the same problem with other mystery and horror novels that I read, where the build up is more exciting than the resolution. Some of the mystery may have been lost in the translation as well (originally written in German).
Overall, the end I ended up only giving the book 2/5 stars on Goodreads but despite that low rating I would still recommend it to anyone looking for a well developed, character driven plot. I do not plan on reading the other three books in The Hangman's Daughter quartet.
Saturday, October 26, 2013
Under My Hat: Tales from the Cauldron - A Review
![]() |
| Image Credit: Goodreads |
(Disclaimer: Gaiman only contributed a poem to this book that is one page long. If you are buying this book solely based on his work, I would suggest checking it out from the library).
All of the stories in this book have a common thread of witches (who and what they are, how to find them and how to kill them, among other things). As with most short story collections, you win some and you lose some. Unfortunately I lost more with this book than I won and can't strongly recommend it to anyone else as a purchase. This book is a great tool for discovering the writing styles of multiple authors and seeing their take on the same topic.
The most frustrating thing I experience with short stories is their lack of depth and their abrupt endings that are critical to their nature. After all, if there was in depth character development and plot lines I would be reading a novel instead of a short story and wouldn't be able to dip in and out of so many writing styles within 400 pages. I don't regret expanding my witch-lore with this book but I don't think I will be trying any short story collections in the near future.
Thursday, October 24, 2013
The Selection - A Review
![]() |
| Image Credit:Amazon.com |
I highly recommend this book! I ate it up and even gave it 5/5 stars on Goodreads because I enjoyed it so much.
I listened to all 8 hours of the audiobook in a row because I could not get enough of America's story and what would happen next. I found myself enraged at some of the decisions America made, the blindness to Maxon's affections towards her and the cruelty of the other girls involved in the hunt for Maxon's hand in marriage. I haven't been emotionally connected to a book like this in a very long time, even though the premise is silly and conventional overdone in YA.
This is not the most well written, complex, or through provoking book that I had ever read. But it was an all around good time and I already have the second book in the series, The Elite, waiting for me on my kindle. I sometimes feel guilty about reading YA books because they aren't widely critically acclaimed or because my colleagues and friends would frown if I recommended them. However. reading is my hobby and hobby should be fun. I haven't had so much fun with a book in a long time.
Monday, October 21, 2013
Doctor Sleep - The Wrap Up!
I missed last week's check in for the Doctor Sleep readalong hosted by Tif Talks Books and Cheap Thrills so I am going to skip ahead for the final discussion questions below.
Warning! If you have not read The Shining or Doctor Sleep you will probably be spoiled!
Discussion #3 - Chapters 14-end
Before we started reading, we asked if you had any expectations for Doctor Sleep. Did you get what you were hoping for out of the book?
I got SO MUCH MORE out of this book than I was expecting! The Shining was lackluster for me, and I saw this book as representing a greater possibility for Danny's character and story line. I read very few synopses and tried to limit my expectations as much as possible so I wouldn't be let down. Stephen King delivered this time - I was so enraptured by this story that I blew threw the book in 2 days and put everything (eating, sleeping) aside until I was done. Even after I was done reading I stayed up for a few hours to read what others thought about the book too.
Having finished the book, do you think having read The Shining is important for enjoying this one?
I think reading The Shining is essential for understanding the interpersonal connections between characters. However, the True Knot brought so much to the story that didn't directly involve the Overlook Hotel that anyone could pick up Doctor Sleep without feeling lost. The prologue to the book also did a great job of recapping what happened in Danny's childhood to provide a good knowledge base for Doctor Sleep.
In one word, one phrase, one sentence ... describe Doctor Sleep.
Wow - it's difficult to pick just one. I think closure is a good one. Danny, Abra, Abra's grandmother, the Overlook - everything wraps up at the end of the book. Bad feelings are put to rest and people are able to move on with their lives without fear of their shining.
Anything else you feel like discussing about the end of the book? Or, about the book as a whole?
Yes - the True Knot! Who are they, where did they come from, how did they start.. I need to know! The True Knot could be a separate novella with an explanation to their history. The mystery surrounding the group enhances to story but the fan in me needs to know whats going on!
As for the True Knot's hunt for Abra using "the grid" (basically the Internet), I think Stephen King was trying to make commentary on how much of our lives are spent, conducted or stored online or in electronic records that are vulnerable to groups or people trying to harm us (like the True Knot). When the True Knot was trying to find Abra and able to so easily determine her location it felt like the internet was the enemy, and it was unsettling. If the True Knot were coming after us, who is to say we couldn't be found just as easily?
So tell me - what are your thoughts?? Did you love it, hate it, couldn't get enough of it?
Warning! If you have not read The Shining or Doctor Sleep you will probably be spoiled!
Discussion #3 - Chapters 14-end
Before we started reading, we asked if you had any expectations for Doctor Sleep. Did you get what you were hoping for out of the book?
I got SO MUCH MORE out of this book than I was expecting! The Shining was lackluster for me, and I saw this book as representing a greater possibility for Danny's character and story line. I read very few synopses and tried to limit my expectations as much as possible so I wouldn't be let down. Stephen King delivered this time - I was so enraptured by this story that I blew threw the book in 2 days and put everything (eating, sleeping) aside until I was done. Even after I was done reading I stayed up for a few hours to read what others thought about the book too.
Having finished the book, do you think having read The Shining is important for enjoying this one?
I think reading The Shining is essential for understanding the interpersonal connections between characters. However, the True Knot brought so much to the story that didn't directly involve the Overlook Hotel that anyone could pick up Doctor Sleep without feeling lost. The prologue to the book also did a great job of recapping what happened in Danny's childhood to provide a good knowledge base for Doctor Sleep.
In one word, one phrase, one sentence ... describe Doctor Sleep.
Wow - it's difficult to pick just one. I think closure is a good one. Danny, Abra, Abra's grandmother, the Overlook - everything wraps up at the end of the book. Bad feelings are put to rest and people are able to move on with their lives without fear of their shining.
Anything else you feel like discussing about the end of the book? Or, about the book as a whole?
Yes - the True Knot! Who are they, where did they come from, how did they start.. I need to know! The True Knot could be a separate novella with an explanation to their history. The mystery surrounding the group enhances to story but the fan in me needs to know whats going on!
As for the True Knot's hunt for Abra using "the grid" (basically the Internet), I think Stephen King was trying to make commentary on how much of our lives are spent, conducted or stored online or in electronic records that are vulnerable to groups or people trying to harm us (like the True Knot). When the True Knot was trying to find Abra and able to so easily determine her location it felt like the internet was the enemy, and it was unsettling. If the True Knot were coming after us, who is to say we couldn't be found just as easily?
So tell me - what are your thoughts?? Did you love it, hate it, couldn't get enough of it?
Thursday, October 17, 2013
Wuthering Heights - A RIPVIII Review
I finished reading Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte during Dewey's 24 Hour Readathon this past weekend. I originally selected the book because it's a classic that I feel everyone else but me had read. I had also never read any Victorian literature, or anything by the Bronte sisters.
In case you didn't know, Wuthering Heights is a multi-generational tale of a love-square involving Cathy, Heathcliffe, Edgar and Isabella who do not get what they want while they are alive. They pass this terrible lifestyle on to their children who are also miserable for 95% of the book. It is not until the final chapter that we see a couple genuinely happy together without extenuating circumstances that pull them apart.
The story is told partially through the perspective of Mr. Lockwood, who is renting Thrushcross Grange a few miles from Wuthering Heights. The first few chapters of this book are the hilarious encounters of mis-manners between Mr. Lockwood and Heathcliffe, his landlord. The rest of the story is told through stories that Nelly, Thrushcross Grange's caretaker, relates to Mr. Lockwood. She grew up at Wuthering Heights with Cathy and Heathcliffe and had first hand experience at all of the horrible events that took place over their lifetimes.
The characters in this book are terrible for the most part. It's not really their fault - they have a lot circumstances they are unable to overcome in the very beginning of their lives - but I think that's what makes the book work so well. You feel terrible for the characters because they were molded into unpleasant people but at the same time they are so unpleasant you love to hate them. The writing was difficult to read because I was not acclimated to the Victorian writing style, but once I was able to focus and sink into the rhythm of the words it made much more sense. However, I think this is a book that needs to be read more than once to be fully understood. I struggled through the book for a while so I don't think I will be reading it again any time soon, but I am willing to look into other people's reviews and discussions to learn more about it.
While reading I highlighted two passages from the book:
Cathy to Nelly regarding Heathcliffe - "It would degrade me to marry Heathcliffe now; so he shall never know how I love him: and that, not because he's handsome, Nelly, but because he's more myself than I am. Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same;" (Chapter 9)
Heathcliffe to Nelly regarding Cathy - "If he loved with all the powers of his puny being, he couldn't love as much in eighty years as I could in a day. And Catherine has a heart as deep as I have: the sea could be as readily contained in that horse-trough as her whole affection be monopolised by him!" (Chatper 14)
Have you read Wuthering Heights? I've heard from some people that absolutely love it and others that hate it. I would love to know what you think!
In case you didn't know, Wuthering Heights is a multi-generational tale of a love-square involving Cathy, Heathcliffe, Edgar and Isabella who do not get what they want while they are alive. They pass this terrible lifestyle on to their children who are also miserable for 95% of the book. It is not until the final chapter that we see a couple genuinely happy together without extenuating circumstances that pull them apart.
The story is told partially through the perspective of Mr. Lockwood, who is renting Thrushcross Grange a few miles from Wuthering Heights. The first few chapters of this book are the hilarious encounters of mis-manners between Mr. Lockwood and Heathcliffe, his landlord. The rest of the story is told through stories that Nelly, Thrushcross Grange's caretaker, relates to Mr. Lockwood. She grew up at Wuthering Heights with Cathy and Heathcliffe and had first hand experience at all of the horrible events that took place over their lifetimes.
The characters in this book are terrible for the most part. It's not really their fault - they have a lot circumstances they are unable to overcome in the very beginning of their lives - but I think that's what makes the book work so well. You feel terrible for the characters because they were molded into unpleasant people but at the same time they are so unpleasant you love to hate them. The writing was difficult to read because I was not acclimated to the Victorian writing style, but once I was able to focus and sink into the rhythm of the words it made much more sense. However, I think this is a book that needs to be read more than once to be fully understood. I struggled through the book for a while so I don't think I will be reading it again any time soon, but I am willing to look into other people's reviews and discussions to learn more about it.
While reading I highlighted two passages from the book:
Cathy to Nelly regarding Heathcliffe - "It would degrade me to marry Heathcliffe now; so he shall never know how I love him: and that, not because he's handsome, Nelly, but because he's more myself than I am. Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same;" (Chapter 9)
Heathcliffe to Nelly regarding Cathy - "If he loved with all the powers of his puny being, he couldn't love as much in eighty years as I could in a day. And Catherine has a heart as deep as I have: the sea could be as readily contained in that horse-trough as her whole affection be monopolised by him!" (Chatper 14)
Have you read Wuthering Heights? I've heard from some people that absolutely love it and others that hate it. I would love to know what you think!
Monday, October 14, 2013
The Historian - Final Check In & Discussion
Hello readers! It's been quite a month so far.. I finished both The Historian and Doctor Sleep within the past few weeks and I've got so many discussion questions to catch up on. Today I will be posting my answers to the final discussion questions for The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova. This readalong event was hosted by The Estella Society for RIPVIII, which ends on October 31.
If you're just catching up you can read my answers to the mid-way discussion here, and I posted my full review on The Historian here.
Just in case you didn't realize - this is a discussion post so if you have not read or finished the book you may be spoiled by my answers!
If you're just catching up you can read my answers to the mid-way discussion here, and I posted my full review on The Historian here.
Just in case you didn't realize - this is a discussion post so if you have not read or finished the book you may be spoiled by my answers!
1. What did you think of the way everything unfolded at the end? Any surprises?
The ending to the book did not shock or surprise me - I think it ended up being pretty predictable once Paul and Helen got to the final church site, and the overall ending of the book tied all of the story ends up quite nicely. I didn't think the additional perspective of Paul and Helen's daughter was completely unnecesary for the ending that Kostova wrote because it only added an additional emotional layer rather than enhancing the plot. Reading everything through her perspective made the story confusing and I would have preferred a narrative rather than epistolary format for the overall book.
2. What did you think of Dracula?
I didn't think Dracula was all that impressive. Is it just me or did anyone else feel that way? The build up to finding him was so great that I didn't even know what to expect and I think that is what led me to being let down. I think it would have been better if they didn't find his tomb or his "presence" and left it as a mystery.
3. In Chapter 73, Dracula states his credo: “History has taught us that the nature of man is evil, sublimely so.” Do the characters and events in the novel seem to agree or disagree with this?
I may have skimmed over this section .. so I will have to pass on this question!
4. Helen’s history is deeply intertwined with Dracula. In what ways are the two characters connected? Does she win out over his legacy?
Dracula and Helen are connected by their culture's history, language and customers on a very basic level, but ultimately their connection morphs into something else over the story. Helen is initially motivated to find more information about Dracula because she is searching for her father and a way to connect with him on a scholarly level - the only way she has to reach out to him. What she discovers when she meets up with Paul is someone who had Rossi as a paternal figure in their life, something she has always wanted. I think this is where Helen's love for Paul comes from, apart from the incredible experience Paul and Helen had together searching for Dracula.
Looking at the surface of the novel I think it is very easy to say that Helen won out over Dracula's legacy because she was able to escape him for years without being turned into a vampire and she was reunited with her family at the end of the story. However, she had to give up so much of herself to searching through history and travelling all over the world to find his tomb to destroy him that she was never able to live her own life. She had to hide in the shadows the same way that he did so I don't think you can definitely say that she won out over his legacy
Overall I think this was a good book worth reading, but it exhausted the novelty of vampires for me this year. I won't be reading any bloodsucking books in the near future!
Friday, October 11, 2013
The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making - A Review
I purchased The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making by Catherynne M. Valente when it was on the Kindle Daily Deal earlier this year. I previously read Valente's Deathless, which is a Russian fairy tale retelling and the language, characters and depth of her stories made me an instant fan.
Fairyland is the story of 12 year old September who is plucked out of her life in Omaha, Nebraska and whisked away to Fairyland by the Green Wind to confront and defeat the current Marquess. Along the way she meets a rich variety of whimsical characters and learns how to depend on herself physically, mentally, and emotionally.
I found September to be a great role model for younger audiences because she is a strong female lead who is successful because she relies on herself. There are many times when she has to decide what is right and what is easy, and she questions her values often while in Fairyland.
Overall, this was a highly engaging novel that I would recommend to anyone who likes fantasy or coming of age stories. It was heartwarming, adventurous, and nostalgic.
The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making is the first in a series of Fairyland books. The a prequel, second & third books are also available.
![]() |
| Image Credit: Goodreads |
Fairyland is the story of 12 year old September who is plucked out of her life in Omaha, Nebraska and whisked away to Fairyland by the Green Wind to confront and defeat the current Marquess. Along the way she meets a rich variety of whimsical characters and learns how to depend on herself physically, mentally, and emotionally.
I found September to be a great role model for younger audiences because she is a strong female lead who is successful because she relies on herself. There are many times when she has to decide what is right and what is easy, and she questions her values often while in Fairyland.
Overall, this was a highly engaging novel that I would recommend to anyone who likes fantasy or coming of age stories. It was heartwarming, adventurous, and nostalgic.
The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making is the first in a series of Fairyland books. The a prequel, second & third books are also available.
Wednesday, October 9, 2013
The Historian - A RIPVIII Review
The Historian is a trip down the rabbit hole of Dracula lore. Told in epistolary format, it is a story within a story within a story to find the tomb of Dracula to determine whether or not he is still alive. Sound confusing? It is. At the end of the book I wasn't sure who's perspective we were reading from or who was writing the letters telling the story. It is also very, very long, weighing in at over 700 pages. It's well written, but often dry and there were portions of the book where I had to completely skip a 200 page primary document (that was made up!). I read this book as part of a readalong hosted by the Estella Society for RIPVIII. I will have the second round of discussion questions posted on October 14th, but I wanted to jot down my thoughts on the book before then. You can read my answers to the first set of discussion questions here.
I really appreciate the depth of information that Kostova embedded in this novel. I don't know anything about the Ottoman or Byzantine empires, so the knowledge included in the story line flowed well even if I didn't always know what they were talking about. Being unaware of the specifics of the history also prevented any inaccuracies from marring the story for me. I really enjoyed the main characters Paul and Helena and their developing relationship. However, the side characters fell short. They were introduced into the story line too conveniently, and without any speculation as to why they were willing to help or believe the main characters in their quest. They were lovely as individuals, and I especially enjoyed the hospitality of Turgut and his wife - but aligning their immediate kindness with the political turmoil in the middle east and eastern European countries at the time did not match up, making the novel fall short.
I really appreciate the depth of information that Kostova embedded in this novel. I don't know anything about the Ottoman or Byzantine empires, so the knowledge included in the story line flowed well even if I didn't always know what they were talking about. Being unaware of the specifics of the history also prevented any inaccuracies from marring the story for me. I really enjoyed the main characters Paul and Helena and their developing relationship. However, the side characters fell short. They were introduced into the story line too conveniently, and without any speculation as to why they were willing to help or believe the main characters in their quest. They were lovely as individuals, and I especially enjoyed the hospitality of Turgut and his wife - but aligning their immediate kindness with the political turmoil in the middle east and eastern European countries at the time did not match up, making the novel fall short.
Wednesday, October 2, 2013
The Historian Readalong - Discussion and Midway Check In
Hello friends! Are you reading The Historian along with me and The Estella Society? This readalong is also a part of RIPVIII.
I am currently 60% through with the book and I a few days late with the discussion questions but I wanted to check in anyway.
1. What do you think of the structure of the novel?
I am loving the story within a story, down the rabbit hole structure of this story. It switches between stories/perspectives enough to maintain suspense and interest without being confusing.
2. What are your thoughts on Helen's characterization? Have you warmed to her?
Actually, it did not occur to me to dislike Helen until I read this question. I never received the overall impression that she was dislikeable, just aloof or stand off-ish. After Kostova developed Helen's character and background more I have grown quite fond of her. I do think she is quite forward for the time period (1950s) and her history of being a women scholar in a communist county doesn't seem very realistic.
3. What do you think of the peripheral characters? Are their motivations pure? (Turget, Helen's family, etc).
I've just started to indulge in the chapters of Helen's family so I haven't fully formed my opinion on them, with the exception of her mother. I do believe her intentions are pure based on the history between her and Rossi. As for the other characters such as Turgut and Professor Hugh came into the story line too easily and offered their backgrounds too readily for me to fully believe they do not have an ulterior motive. Even in the historic academic world I find it hard to believe that anyone will accept the theory that Dracula is still alive. I think their eagerness to assist (monetarily, personally) on this investigation for Dracula is for their benefit rather than Paul's.
4. Other thoughts on this book?
Loving it! I originally read the first 20% or so and set it down for no reason. I picked it back up for this reading challenge and I am so glad I did. I am enthralled in the stories and settings and can't wait to find out. I think it's a great compliment to Kostova that I can fall deeply into her writing (on a topic that seems boring on the surface) for a few hours at a time without losing interest or falling asleep.
I am currently 60% through with the book and I a few days late with the discussion questions but I wanted to check in anyway.
1. What do you think of the structure of the novel?
I am loving the story within a story, down the rabbit hole structure of this story. It switches between stories/perspectives enough to maintain suspense and interest without being confusing.
2. What are your thoughts on Helen's characterization? Have you warmed to her?
Actually, it did not occur to me to dislike Helen until I read this question. I never received the overall impression that she was dislikeable, just aloof or stand off-ish. After Kostova developed Helen's character and background more I have grown quite fond of her. I do think she is quite forward for the time period (1950s) and her history of being a women scholar in a communist county doesn't seem very realistic.
3. What do you think of the peripheral characters? Are their motivations pure? (Turget, Helen's family, etc).
I've just started to indulge in the chapters of Helen's family so I haven't fully formed my opinion on them, with the exception of her mother. I do believe her intentions are pure based on the history between her and Rossi. As for the other characters such as Turgut and Professor Hugh came into the story line too easily and offered their backgrounds too readily for me to fully believe they do not have an ulterior motive. Even in the historic academic world I find it hard to believe that anyone will accept the theory that Dracula is still alive. I think their eagerness to assist (monetarily, personally) on this investigation for Dracula is for their benefit rather than Paul's.
4. Other thoughts on this book?
Loving it! I originally read the first 20% or so and set it down for no reason. I picked it back up for this reading challenge and I am so glad I did. I am enthralled in the stories and settings and can't wait to find out. I think it's a great compliment to Kostova that I can fall deeply into her writing (on a topic that seems boring on the surface) for a few hours at a time without losing interest or falling asleep.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
The Witches Review
Confession: I am nearly 25 years old and this is the first Roald Dahl book I've ever read. I was a reader as a child, too- always in the library at school or in my town. I've seen the movies inspired by his books but if you had asked my 9 year old self who Roald Dahl was I wouldn't have any idea.
I decided to fix the oversight in my children's literature experience by reading The Witches. This read was inspired by quite a few sources - Julia Pistell from Literary Disco recommended The Witches in their podcast, Chels from Chels&ABook hauled quite a few books from Roald Dahl over the summer AND it was just Roald Dahl Day on September 13! So, I hopped on Amazon and purchased The Witches and read it in one day.
The Witches tells the story of a 9 year old boy who is orphaned and then raised by his Norwegian grandmama. Grandmama is quite the story teller and we learn an incredible amount of information about the existence of witches throughout the world - how to spot them, what their motives are, and best of all -- how to get rid of them.
My favorite part of Roald Dahl's writing is when he breaks down the fourth wall and speaks directly to the reader (usually a child). I remember this being present in many other books I read when I was younger and I loved it. It makes the child feel special, like the author is recognizing their important role in the art of story telling and making sure they are paying attention to everything is going on. Dahl also plays up children's humor very well (and tastefully) and I found it quite funny as an adult. Here is an example when describing how to tell witches from regular women:
HOW GREAT IS THAT? I can picture a classroom of children going wild while their teacher/maybe witch reads this aloud to them. It is a great way to engage the child in reading and keep them coming back for more.
Overall, this was a fantastic read and I will be purchasing more Roald Dahl books in the future!
I decided to fix the oversight in my children's literature experience by reading The Witches. This read was inspired by quite a few sources - Julia Pistell from Literary Disco recommended The Witches in their podcast, Chels from Chels&ABook hauled quite a few books from Roald Dahl over the summer AND it was just Roald Dahl Day on September 13! So, I hopped on Amazon and purchased The Witches and read it in one day.
![]() |
| Image Source: Amazon.com |
My favorite part of Roald Dahl's writing is when he breaks down the fourth wall and speaks directly to the reader (usually a child). I remember this being present in many other books I read when I was younger and I loved it. It makes the child feel special, like the author is recognizing their important role in the art of story telling and making sure they are paying attention to everything is going on. Dahl also plays up children's humor very well (and tastefully) and I found it quite funny as an adult. Here is an example when describing how to tell witches from regular women:
She might even - and this will make you jump - she might even be your lovely school-teacher who is reading these words to you at this very moment. Look carefully at that teacher. Perhaps she is smiling at the absurdity of such a suggestion. Don't let that put you off. It could be part of her cleverness.
I am not, of course, telling you for one second that your teacher is actually a witch. All I am saying is that she might be one. It is most unlikely. But - and here comes the big "but" - it is not impossible. (c) Dahl, 1983.
HOW GREAT IS THAT? I can picture a classroom of children going wild while their teacher/maybe witch reads this aloud to them. It is a great way to engage the child in reading and keep them coming back for more.
Overall, this was a fantastic read and I will be purchasing more Roald Dahl books in the future!
Saturday, September 7, 2013
Fahrenheit 451 Review - Classics Club
I recently finished Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury as part of my Classics Club Commitment and for the Classics Spin #3.
This book is so popular and frequently assigned to high school students that I am not going to recap the events here. After finishing the book I was left with a "huh?" feeling. The first 130 or so pages demonstrate Guy Montag's struggle against himself and the society in which he lives; he finally finds a release through the discovery of literature.
However, immediately after the climax of the book Bradbury takes Montag into a path that I neither saw coming nor understood. Once he meets up with the other literary scholars along the railroad tracks I have absolutely no idea what Bradbury was saying. All of a sudden the focus became on the limits of human society in comparison with nature as a whole and I did not understand how that related to the previous societal conflict. Overall this was just an average book for me. I may have to read it again to put the puzzle pieces together on what Bradbury was trying to do at the end; I don't think I fully grasped his message (the same thing happened with The Great Gatsby, I read the book three times before I could connect with the plot, let alone the meaning behind it).
Have you read Fahrenheit 451 and understood it, or did you also have difficulty understanding Bradbury's message? Let me know (or help explain) in the comments!
Fahrenheit 451 was originally published in 1953 by Ballantine Books.
![]() |
| Image Source: Amazon.com |
This book is so popular and frequently assigned to high school students that I am not going to recap the events here. After finishing the book I was left with a "huh?" feeling. The first 130 or so pages demonstrate Guy Montag's struggle against himself and the society in which he lives; he finally finds a release through the discovery of literature.
However, immediately after the climax of the book Bradbury takes Montag into a path that I neither saw coming nor understood. Once he meets up with the other literary scholars along the railroad tracks I have absolutely no idea what Bradbury was saying. All of a sudden the focus became on the limits of human society in comparison with nature as a whole and I did not understand how that related to the previous societal conflict. Overall this was just an average book for me. I may have to read it again to put the puzzle pieces together on what Bradbury was trying to do at the end; I don't think I fully grasped his message (the same thing happened with The Great Gatsby, I read the book three times before I could connect with the plot, let alone the meaning behind it).
Have you read Fahrenheit 451 and understood it, or did you also have difficulty understanding Bradbury's message? Let me know (or help explain) in the comments!
Fahrenheit 451 was originally published in 1953 by Ballantine Books.
Friday, September 6, 2013
The Night Circus Review - A RIPVIII Read
I have a confession - I did not finish this book. I am listening to the audiobook and I have about 2.5 hours left, but I can't bring myself to listen to them despite having a story line I was initially interested in and beautiful writing, not the mention the rich voice of Jim Dale.
The Night Circus follows three story lines: the challenge between Celia and Marco, the creation and characters of the circus, and Bailey, a young man from Concord, Massachusetts who wishes to be rescued by the circus like so many characters in fairy tales. It really is too complex to try and explain to someone without spoiling; each detail builds upon the one before it and eventually manifest into a bigger picture.
These story lines are interwoven through multiple decades by the phenomenal writing of Erin Morgenstern. She has the ability to describe setting, character and dialogue utilizing all five senses and I was immersed in the story line from the very first line.
So what happened?
The Night Circus is written with vignettes that jump across decades, continents, and story lines. While this normally isn't a problem to read, listening to a story written in this form is an entirely different and confusing experience. I could only listen to the book for about an hour at a time without getting antsy so a book that would normally take me 1-2 days to read would eventually elapse into a 13 day listening experience due to the length of the audio. Even when I forced myself to listen to a few hours per day, I would mentally wander or distract myself with something else. I think if the story was told in a more linear manner I wouldn't have such a difficult time with the book.
Despite my inability to finish the audio version of The Night Circus I might still pick up a physical copy of the book to read so I can finish the story. I would highly recommend this book, especially for an event like RIPVIII because it was generally creepy at the very beginning and has an overall, fantasy/noir feel.
The Night Circus was published in 2011 by Anchor Books.
The Night Circus follows three story lines: the challenge between Celia and Marco, the creation and characters of the circus, and Bailey, a young man from Concord, Massachusetts who wishes to be rescued by the circus like so many characters in fairy tales. It really is too complex to try and explain to someone without spoiling; each detail builds upon the one before it and eventually manifest into a bigger picture.
These story lines are interwoven through multiple decades by the phenomenal writing of Erin Morgenstern. She has the ability to describe setting, character and dialogue utilizing all five senses and I was immersed in the story line from the very first line.
So what happened?
The Night Circus is written with vignettes that jump across decades, continents, and story lines. While this normally isn't a problem to read, listening to a story written in this form is an entirely different and confusing experience. I could only listen to the book for about an hour at a time without getting antsy so a book that would normally take me 1-2 days to read would eventually elapse into a 13 day listening experience due to the length of the audio. Even when I forced myself to listen to a few hours per day, I would mentally wander or distract myself with something else. I think if the story was told in a more linear manner I wouldn't have such a difficult time with the book.
Despite my inability to finish the audio version of The Night Circus I might still pick up a physical copy of the book to read so I can finish the story. I would highly recommend this book, especially for an event like RIPVIII because it was generally creepy at the very beginning and has an overall, fantasy/noir feel.
The Night Circus was published in 2011 by Anchor Books.
Sunday, August 25, 2013
Legend Book Review
I recently finished reading Legend by Marie Lu as part of my Bout of Books 8.0 read-a-thon. There has been a lot of praise for Lu's writing over the past few months, and with the final book being released in November I figured it was time to see what all of the hype was about. I gave this book three out of five stars on Goodreads.
Legend is the first in the dystopian trilogy chronicling the lives of Day and June who live in the Republic (formerly the west coast of the United States). At first, Day and June's geographic locations are the only thing drawing them together. Day is the poor, vagabond enemy of the Republic and June is their prodigy military student from a prominent family. Legend details the personal and political circumstances that bring the two protagonists together.
Overall, this was a good book and I have already placed a hold at my library for the second book in the series, Prodigy. Legend didn't blow me away, probably because I have read so many YA dystopian series since the genre was popularized by the Hunger Games in early 2012, but I did enjoy reading it. I was hesitant when I first heard it was written from two different character perspectives. Neil Schusterman used this format in Unwind and I really disliked it because it was so repetitive. But Lu did an excellent job using the two person perspective to create a whole picture of life in the Republic and gave an equal footing to both protagonists perspectives. The developing relationship between Day and June, and the plot in general, was a little predictable but there were a few scenes that shocked me (ending of Part 1 in particular) that made the book just different enough to hold my attention.
The lack of exposition regarding the Republic vs. Colony world both Day and June live in was the main flaw of the book. I did not read any previous reviews or the actual synopsis on the book jacket so I had no idea why the Republic and the Colonies were at war, or how long the war had lasted. Without the background information of the world that Day and June live in I had very little sympathy toward the Republic their military dictatorship.
Legend was published in 2013 by Speak.
Legend is the first in the dystopian trilogy chronicling the lives of Day and June who live in the Republic (formerly the west coast of the United States). At first, Day and June's geographic locations are the only thing drawing them together. Day is the poor, vagabond enemy of the Republic and June is their prodigy military student from a prominent family. Legend details the personal and political circumstances that bring the two protagonists together.
Overall, this was a good book and I have already placed a hold at my library for the second book in the series, Prodigy. Legend didn't blow me away, probably because I have read so many YA dystopian series since the genre was popularized by the Hunger Games in early 2012, but I did enjoy reading it. I was hesitant when I first heard it was written from two different character perspectives. Neil Schusterman used this format in Unwind and I really disliked it because it was so repetitive. But Lu did an excellent job using the two person perspective to create a whole picture of life in the Republic and gave an equal footing to both protagonists perspectives. The developing relationship between Day and June, and the plot in general, was a little predictable but there were a few scenes that shocked me (ending of Part 1 in particular) that made the book just different enough to hold my attention.
The lack of exposition regarding the Republic vs. Colony world both Day and June live in was the main flaw of the book. I did not read any previous reviews or the actual synopsis on the book jacket so I had no idea why the Republic and the Colonies were at war, or how long the war had lasted. Without the background information of the world that Day and June live in I had very little sympathy toward the Republic their military dictatorship.
Legend was published in 2013 by Speak.
Thursday, August 22, 2013
The Jessica Darling Series - Books 1-3
During my participation in Bout of Books 8.0 and the Dog Days of Summer Marathon, I decided to revisit Jessica Darling in the series of books written by Megan McCafferty in the early 2000s – a reread of the first three installments Sloppy Firsts, Second Helpings, Charmed Thirds, and finishing out the series with Fourth Comings and Perfect Fifths.
The first two books chronicle Jessica Darling’s life in Pineville, NJ during her sophomore and junior years of high school. The books start immediately after her best friend Hope moved across country to Tennessee due to a tragic event due to the death of her older brother, Heath. Now best friend-less, Jessica is trying to navigate the waters of a high school where she feels like an outsider and fit in with a family that all seem to get along without her. During her post-Hope depression, Jessica encounters Marcus Flutie in seemingly harmless episodes until an event that occurs at the end of book one, which forges an awkward and unspoken relationship between them. The first two books wouldn't be complete without the cast of characters that inhabits Pineville: The Clueless Crew, Scotty, Len Levy (Jessica’s first heartbreak), Paul Parlipiano, Jessica’s parents and much older sister Bethany.
Rereading Sloppy Firsts and Second Helpings was like stepping back into my own 15 year old body. The wear and tear imparted on my copies of these books clearly show I have read them more than 2 or 3 times and I revisited them frequently throughout high school. Jessica is an extremely flawed character – hyper observant to the point of judgmental, her friends cannot escape the mental stereotypes she applies to them (and herself). She blames her inability to fit in with friends/family on everyone when her own malaise and anxiety are what causes the separation. Jessica’s honest portrayal of high school made her seem so real, her emotions were tangible and the confusion of where she fit in with school, friends, and family made her relate-able in a way that most authors cannot communicate with their readers. These qualities made me pick the book up time and time again.
Another portion of the books that I loved, more for nostalgia than anything else, are the pop culture references McCafferty makes during the time period (2000-2003). Mentions of TRL and MTV’s Spring Break specials instantly time warped me back to middle and high school and watching these programs play out on TV.
Compared to the first two books, Charmed Thirds was a let down for me. This books chronicles Jessica's senior year of high school through all four years of college at Columbia University. It's written in season blocks, rather than months, so it was like a drive by of her college years rather than the daily insights and issues Jessica faced in high school. While this allowed the book to span five years in just under 400 pages, it also disconnected Jessica from the reader. The witty banter that made the first two books was still present in Charmed Thirds, so the reading experience was enjoyable, but other elements of the book made it a flop.
The worst part of the book was the lack of personal growth. There was no discernible difference in Jessica's personality or outlook on life, peers, school or family from the first two books. Now, Jessica's negative disposition on life ends up being annoying rather than angst-y. This, coupled with the bizarre on again-off again relationship with Marcus, made the book disappointed. I felt like this book was a bridge between adolescent and adult life for Jessica and I would have been thoroughly disappointed if I had known there were not two more books to potentially redeem the story line.
Sloppy Firsts was published in 2001 by Broadway Books, Second Helpings was published in 2003 by Three Rivers Press, and Charmed Thirds was published in 2007 by Broadway Books.
The first two books chronicle Jessica Darling’s life in Pineville, NJ during her sophomore and junior years of high school. The books start immediately after her best friend Hope moved across country to Tennessee due to a tragic event due to the death of her older brother, Heath. Now best friend-less, Jessica is trying to navigate the waters of a high school where she feels like an outsider and fit in with a family that all seem to get along without her. During her post-Hope depression, Jessica encounters Marcus Flutie in seemingly harmless episodes until an event that occurs at the end of book one, which forges an awkward and unspoken relationship between them. The first two books wouldn't be complete without the cast of characters that inhabits Pineville: The Clueless Crew, Scotty, Len Levy (Jessica’s first heartbreak), Paul Parlipiano, Jessica’s parents and much older sister Bethany.
Rereading Sloppy Firsts and Second Helpings was like stepping back into my own 15 year old body. The wear and tear imparted on my copies of these books clearly show I have read them more than 2 or 3 times and I revisited them frequently throughout high school. Jessica is an extremely flawed character – hyper observant to the point of judgmental, her friends cannot escape the mental stereotypes she applies to them (and herself). She blames her inability to fit in with friends/family on everyone when her own malaise and anxiety are what causes the separation. Jessica’s honest portrayal of high school made her seem so real, her emotions were tangible and the confusion of where she fit in with school, friends, and family made her relate-able in a way that most authors cannot communicate with their readers. These qualities made me pick the book up time and time again.
Another portion of the books that I loved, more for nostalgia than anything else, are the pop culture references McCafferty makes during the time period (2000-2003). Mentions of TRL and MTV’s Spring Break specials instantly time warped me back to middle and high school and watching these programs play out on TV.
Compared to the first two books, Charmed Thirds was a let down for me. This books chronicles Jessica's senior year of high school through all four years of college at Columbia University. It's written in season blocks, rather than months, so it was like a drive by of her college years rather than the daily insights and issues Jessica faced in high school. While this allowed the book to span five years in just under 400 pages, it also disconnected Jessica from the reader. The witty banter that made the first two books was still present in Charmed Thirds, so the reading experience was enjoyable, but other elements of the book made it a flop.
The worst part of the book was the lack of personal growth. There was no discernible difference in Jessica's personality or outlook on life, peers, school or family from the first two books. Now, Jessica's negative disposition on life ends up being annoying rather than angst-y. This, coupled with the bizarre on again-off again relationship with Marcus, made the book disappointed. I felt like this book was a bridge between adolescent and adult life for Jessica and I would have been thoroughly disappointed if I had known there were not two more books to potentially redeem the story line.
Sloppy Firsts was published in 2001 by Broadway Books, Second Helpings was published in 2003 by Three Rivers Press, and Charmed Thirds was published in 2007 by Broadway Books.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













